Anyone who knows me knows that I'm an aficionado of webcomics. I've got way too many that I read on a daily basis, and ten times that bookmarked for a rainy day. Used to be, once upon a time, that I used this very journal to write up reviews and commentary on certain comics, if for nothing else than to educate/inform the public of what little gems they were missing out on.
That, however, was quite some time back, and things have changed a little. First and foremost, my own particular brand of vitriolic insight is somewhat archaic at this point, mostly due to the talented man over at
WebSnark, who does a better job of reading and reviewing internet comics than I could ever even hope to. And, even more so than when I first put up my reviews, the face of online comics has changed--Strips are coming and going at a rate that is nigh-impossible for me to even begin to track, and we're even starting to see the lines blur between web-based comics and traditional print comics (Scott Kurtz is a putz, but I still say he's on the right track).
All that being said, though, there's a little something that I feel as though I need to comment on.
I really can't recall if I ever went off on Cory You or not, but I think it's high time I did. Mr. You, for those who arn't aware, has been the owner and artist behind a comic called
PockyBot for quite some time now, and has managed to gain my ire like no one before him honestly has. Here's how.
I stumbled across PockyBot via some random banner link--I can't remember for the life of me what site it was on, but I know that the banner in question had some interesting and rather colorful artwork, so I decided to head over and check it out. What followed confused the ever loving hell out of me.
People of this day and age enjoy randomness. They watch Invader Zim and chuckle every time Gir says something completely idiotic. They see clips of monkeys interspersed with ninjas, blocks of color swirling, the theme from the Benny Hill Show playing in the background, and some text that reads "HOLY BANANA"... and this is entertainment. And, really, I can understand it. There's nothing wrong with randomness. It can actually be amusing, in a pure, simple "what the hell did I just watch?" kind of way.
However, when you start basing your entire premise on sheer random events, then you have a problem.
PockyBot was everything that I loathed about the youth of today. An unending calvacade of things that made no sense, along with highly-stylized attempts at creating catch phrases and underground images that were so transparent you could have walked right through them. The sheer name "PockyBot" is nothing more than an attempt to interject randomness with a tie to 'underground culture' (again, using the term loosely) by playing off people's love of Pocky (which is a rant in and of itself, really).
The strips refused any form of continuity, and instead loosely connected some form of MMORPG world in which literally anything could happen. And did. Constantly. Leaving strips feeling less like something that maintained a coherent world and more like something that was simply thrown together for the sake of having nothing better to do. Even this wouldn't have bothered me, had it not been for the pervasive cloying attitude that emanated from every word Mr. You typed. His constant meandering on the "3am Dreaming" and other such idiotic nonsense gave way to a thin veil of hyperbole, one that did nothing but attempt to play upon other people's desire to 'get the joke'. Little did they know, there was no joke to get.
The worst part about this is that, in their desire to understand what the hell was going on (and between pretending to understand what it was all about, just to look good to everyone else), the comic gained a *fanbase*. Not only a fanbase, but a rather rabid one at that--Granted, we all know how fangirls and idiotic otaku can be, but still. In this case, we saw the website begin to gain a rather large amount of notoriety and fame, even garnering positive reviews in the small circle that exists to do such things.
All I could do was sit back, shake my head, and wonder what the fuck was wrong with these people.
Fast forward to today. With as much as this shameful abortion of a 'comic' disgusted me, I naturally just walked away and didn't even look through it again. But, something in my mind happened to think about it today, and I wandered over to the PockyBot website... and was not really expecting what I found.
First and foremost, if you're looking for any examples of what I listed above, they're not there. Mr. You has summarily removed them from the site. Secondly, you'll notice a comic there, but it has continuity, a standard joke setup/punchline, and... no random weirdness. So what happened?
Plain and simple, I can tell you *exactly* what happened. My dreams came true, and a large group of idiots wizened up. They got smart. They finally realized that bsolutly nothing was happening, and they stopped paying attention to the hyperbole. And I really can't tell you how much this makes me smile. Yes, yes, I realize that the blurb under the 'first' comic says that the original version of PockyBot was halted due to real life conflicts and his desire to concentrate on music. Don't buy it for a heartbeat. He realized that it wasn't working--In fact, this isn't his first attempt at reworking the comic. He tried, shortly before I gave up, to interject some form of story and continuity into the entire thing, and quickly gave up.
So what is he doing now? A gaming comic. An office humour comic. A comic that is bland and mediocre beyond any and all belief. And why is he doing this? Because it's a proven formula that works. It's the same shit that's been done a billion times before, and tends to bring in people. It's cliche. It's drab. It's overdone. And he's hoping that people will eat it up.
My hope is that the populace will not be fooled. They woke up once and escaped before it was too late. They saw that they were being fooled, and jumped ship. They caused him to falter, change step, re-think his game... and I'm hoping they'll do that again.
In the very unlikely event that Mr. You reads this, I offer the following advice: You're talented. Your artwork is good, and different. After seeing your attempts to create a "3am Rev0lUt10n" (or however the fuck you leeted it), I know you'd have a brilliant career in logo/graphic design. And, while I have yet to listen to any of your music, given your list of inspirations, I'm sure it'd be something that I would enjoy.
But when it comes to your attempts at fooling the populace? You lose. Not only do you lose, but you lose in the worst way--In the sense that everyone can see *exactly* what it is you're doing, and how you're doing it. While the general population of suckers are even more vast now than they were 100 years ago, you are nowhere near P.T. Barnum, and we are not amused.
... all that being said, maybe I *should* retake my position as a comic commentator. Mr. Burns over at WebSnark has insight into the comic world that I couldn't even begin to grasp, but (despite the 'snark' title), he tends to be rather kind to most people. I am decidedly *not*. And, really, the webcomics world could use a dose of venom that isn't somehow related to
Squidi.